So yes, I now think Oswald acted alone. The government wasn't co-opted by an evil conspiracy, it was just a bureaucratic rat's nest of petty infighting and incompetence. Jul 31, Michael Dorosh rated it it was amazing. I too strongly believed that a conspiracy was responsible, and I enjoyed the film JFK. However, I think Posner does a very good job of refuting many of the conspiracy theories, even those approaching credibility. The book, as pointed out by other reviewers elsewhere, is not perfect. And I admit I don't have a firm grasp on the minutiae of the case that has propelled so many theorists into infamy.
However, on a basic "gut" level, the book feels right. My endorsement of the book goes beyond feelings.
The case is made with solid documentary evidence, though much of it comes from the Warren Report itself which may invalidate it in the eyes of the harshest critics. New research, such as Max Holland is doing with the LBJ tapes, is bringing much to light, and the passing of Jacqueline Kennedy and John Kennedy Junior may hasten the opening of some files within my lifetime.
It is hard to imagine that these files would contain anything startlingly out of sync with the "official" explanation behind the assassination. Posner does expect the reader to have a working knowledge of some facets of the case beyond that of the layman, so be advised the book may not be aimed at them.
The language is not overly scholarly or dense, however, and there are some interesting appendices, diagrams and photographs to support some of the discussion. The book is logically organized into different areas of interest, and is easily read. The book may seem superficial to entrenched conspiracy theorists, who would probably need a more detailed point-by-point rebuttal of their pet theories, which is fine.
Case Closed: Lee Harvey Oswald and the Assassination of JFK - Gerald Posner - Google книги
As a general knowledge book, I think Case Closed successfully demolishes several theories quite handily, though in a very generalized manner. Posner could be busy for the next 99 years if he decided to refute each single theory or book about the assassination one by one. Given the amount of ink that has been spilled over this issue, no single volume could ever hope to refute all that has been written.
Recommended to all, whether you are a conspiracy theorist, a backer of the Warren Commission, or honestly undecided or completely ignorant of the entire case. All you need is an open mind to get value from the book. All the same, much food for thought. May 19, murph rated it it was amazing. An absolute must read for the skeptical mind.
Case Closed : Lee Harvey Oswald and the Assassination of JFK
A lot has been written on the subject of Pres. Kennedy's death - and far too much of it has taken the format of reading the Warren Commission looking for language that justifies the author's pet theory. Posner turns this model on its head and goes after the theories that claim a conspiracy vast or otherwise was the the death of JFK. Many of these theories have been quoted so often for so long that their questionable origin escapes scrutiny. Posner ta An absolute must read for the skeptical mind. Posner takes conspiratorial sacred cows like the "magic bullet" and basically beats them senseless.
Moreover, and more importantly - Posner follows the life of Lee Harvey Oswald in exhaustive detail. In his estimation, Oswald's pathetic existence is not one destined to be a man of mystery, a CIA spy, or even a pasty. Whatever your take on the assassination of JFK, experiencing the counterpoints to the conspiracies will add a great deal to your understanding of what really happened in Dealy Plaza. Mar 19, Brittany rated it liked it.
Although I enjoyed this book, I still am undecided about any final conclusion. Throughout the book, it felt like the author had an agenda- he wanted to prove that Lee Harvey Oswald was the sole assassin and presented the evidence with that in mind. That's not to say I didn't think Posner's research was impressive and did blow some conspiracy theories out of the water, because he did.
I have heard that Vincent Bugliosi's Reclaiming History is the definitive book out there for the lone gunman theo Although I enjoyed this book, I still am undecided about any final conclusion. I have heard that Vincent Bugliosi's Reclaiming History is the definitive book out there for the lone gunman theory and I wish I would have read that first. Posner had this very pompous and dismissive way of writing about every single author and even witnesses that don't support his theory, going so far in his footnotes to comment on their privates lives.
While that isn't a valid criticism on his theory, I just think it's a crappy thing to do and makes me think less of Posner in general. It is of course impossible to review a book on this topic. If you want to come at the subject with an open mind and tackle a reference that attempts a fair and comprehensive analysis, this would be the way to go. If this book doesn't finally convince you of that, then you cannot be convinced.
Few books can plausibly claim to be a definitive It is of course impossible to review a book on this topic.
- Case closed : Lee Harvey Oswald and the assassination of JFK?
- Case closed : Lee Harvey Oswald and the assassination of JFK (Book, ) [isatasfun.tk]!
- Case Closed: Lee Harvey Oswald and the Assassination of JFK.
- Case Closed: Lee Harvey Oswald and the Assassination of JFK (Unabridged) on Apple Books?
- My Nights With Kate (Jack Ryker Book 1).
- Caribbean Twilight: Tales of the Supernatural?
- Baltimore Sun - We are currently unavailable in your region.
Few books can plausibly claim to be a definitive work. This one comes damn close, probably as close as possible. Case Closed, indeed. Jan 22, Vince rated it it was ok.
JFK Assassination Case Closed But the Conspiracy Refuses to Die!
I read the first 7 chapters or so, before I started to wonder how accurate the book is. According to Wikipedia, the author caught a lot of flak for not being fair in his portrayal of Oswald. Vincent Bugliosi who is a bit of a scourge agrees with Posner that Oswald acted alone, nevertheless believes that the case put forward here is too simplistic. Oct 15, Chris rated it it was ok. Posner can eat one. He raises more questions than answers and doesn't provide very convincing arguments as to how Oswald could so easily get in and out of Russia with a Russian bride during the Cold War.
With an open mind, readers of Case Closed should find it hard to disagree with Posner's conclusions, but most Americans today still believe there was a conspiracy of some kind to kill President Kennedy.
Find a copy online
Posner addresses most of the favorite and more viable conspiracies, but still faced a backlash that led to additional explanations in his edition of this book. The first half of this text is a biography of Lee Harvey Oswald, as evidence convincingly identifies him as the murderer, and one mu With an open mind, readers of Case Closed should find it hard to disagree with Posner's conclusions, but most Americans today still believe there was a conspiracy of some kind to kill President Kennedy.
The first half of this text is a biography of Lee Harvey Oswald, as evidence convincingly identifies him as the murderer, and one must know his character to be able to assess his reliability as a conspirator and his claim to be a patsy. Then there are chapters solely dedicated to the second-by-second story of the horror in Dealey Plaza and the forensics of the case afterward. Posner calls out where many mistakes were made along the way, each of which has become the basis for one conspiracy or another.
Case Closed: Lee Harvey Oswald and the Assassination of JFK
Posner is sometimes quick to dismiss statements from witnesses, but it is easy to understand the desire for people to become part of the story--and to sell their own. Personally, I am not sure how open my own mind was, so this book was preaching to the choir. But I know of dozens of conspiracy theories, many of them conflicting with each other, and have learned that most of them would require too many participants to make them practical.
I am a believer in Occam's Razor: When many hypotheses exist, the simplest one tends to be the best choice. The facts as Posner presents them as well as the people closest to the events, and science itself agree completely. Jul 09, Randy rated it it was amazing. Thoroughly dismantles any ideas about a conspiracy to kill JFK. While the book can be tedious at times, it's no fault of the author; instead, it's evidence of his dilligence. This should be required reading for anyone who believes there was a conspiracy to kill JFK, but it's also a fascinating insight into how historians are able to reconstruct an incredibly complicated event that happened more than 50 years ago.
Jul 12, Emese Klencsar-Karpov rated it liked it. It was a little too detailed for me, but I am not really into this topic, maybe if i were searching for clues like somebody extremely interested in the Kennedy assassination I would have found it a lighter read.